Monterey County workers win back pay!

Auditor ordered to pay workers by March 1, with penalties

Pictured from left – Nick Diaz (NMC), Max Stone (DSES), Anne Yen (our SEIU Attorney), and Don Clark (911) on the day of an arbitration hearing.

If you were short-changed on overtime wages between August 28, 2010 and September 18, 2011, your back pay is finally on the horizon.

For more than two years, SEIU 521 members demanded that County Auditor Mike Miller pay employees what they are owed after his $22 million payroll system miscalculated overtime wages during those 13 months.

Now an arbitrator has determined the County violated our MOUs and ordered that Miller pay all SEIU members what they are owed by March 1, 2013. The arbitrator also ordered that all SEIU members receive an additional 10% of their back wages owed. If Miller fails to comply with the deadline, the penalty will increase to 20%.

Read the decision (PDF)

This is a huge win for SEIU 521 members. Workers and their SEIU Contract Enforcement Department filed four grievances on behalf of 2,700 county employees, and SEIU member leaders have gone back and forth with County management to determine why employee paychecks were botched up and how to fix it. After two years of empty promises from the County, we took our grievances to a neutral arbitrator.

Although the County claimed our MOUs were not violated, and that our MOUs were “vague and ambiguous,” the arbitrator determined otherwise.

Max Stone

Max Stone, DSES

“The arbitrator confirmed what we already knew: the payroll system conversion has been a catastrophe that cheated many of us out of our pay. After two years of patiently waiting for a paycheck, giving the Auditor more time is not acceptable. I want to thank our SEIU overtime grievance members for their continued support to see this through and right the wrong by the Auditor’s payroll system.”
— Max Stone, DSES

Nick Diaz, NMC

Nick Diaz, NMC

“As SEIU members, I think we have more perseverance and tenacity than the Auditor ever expected. We proved that he’s been dragging his feet in paying us what we are rightfully owed. Now, there should be no more excuses, or we will hold the Auditor accountable to the Board of Supervisors, the CAO, and, as a last resort, the voters who elected him – us.”
— Nick Diaz, Natividad Medical Center

Who is affected?

At this time there is no official list of who is affected by this and what they are owed. The arbitrator’s decision forces the auditor to compile this information. Stay tuned for more updates on this issue.

Binding arbitration: the next big fight

What is binding arbitration? It’s arguably the most important part of our contract. It’s the leverage we use to protect employees from abuse and ensure managers follow rules. When our union files a grievance over a contract violation or to protest a wrongful discharge, the dispute often leads to a hearing before a neutral judge, or arbitrator, whose decision is final and binding. Hence, “binding arbitration.”

Some contracts do not have binding arbitration, and the final decider of a grievance is often a top-level administrator. In Monterey County, we have enjoyed binding arbitration for many years, and the County has never challenged the binding effect of arbitration decisions… until now. After losing a number of disciplinary appeals in recent years, the County has suddenly taken a position that disciplinary arbitration is not final and binding. Therefore, if an arbitrator orders management to reinstate an employee, certain county attorneys believe the order can be ignored. They are wrong. Eliminating binding arbitration is a huge change to our contract. SEIU recently filed an unfair practice charge against County attorneys in response to their unilateral change. In the months ahead, stay tuned for more information as we fight to preserve this very important contract protection: Binding arbitration.

Monterey County Payroll Action Team

Monterey County Payroll Action Team

The Payroll Action Team included:
Michael Beck
Don Clark
Nick Diaz
Diego Quevedo
Max Stone
Roger VanHorn
Tammy Young

Did you like this? Share it:

5 Responses to “Monterey County workers win back pay!”

  1. Matt Nathanson says:

    Congratulations to all Monterey County Chapter SEIU members. What a great victory. You all earned this money – twice! First by working the overtime, and then by fighting the good fight on these grievances. Thank-you!

  2. Jay Donato says:

    Wow – great job Montery County members. This is the gold standard in Website postings!

  3. Julie Nix says:

    This is a great “win” for the members. Too bad all the all the member leaders aren’t mentioned here. They all out in a lot of hours bargaining this. Thanks to a couple I know are not mentioned, Juan Diego Quevedo and Dr Michael Beck.

    • SEIU Local 521 says:

      We added a list of member leaders who were part of the Payroll Action Team. Thanks for pointing this out, Julie.

  4. Give credit where credit is due. As government employees we work to lead other employees in the community. Therefore, government employees should behave as role model in the community. We need accountability, responsibility and transparency in doing our job. Be fair to your employees as you want to be treated fairly. Be a Good Leader!


Comments about Monterey County workers win back pay! are welcome. Off-topic comments and other violations of our community guidelines may be withheld or removed. Comments do not appear immediately after posting.

Leave a Reply